The 8 Best And 8 Worst 2024 Midsize Trucks, Ranked By The Numbers
The 2024 midsize truck market has its fair share of surprises.
Some trucks, like the Chevrolet Colorado, impressed with fresh designs and solid performance, while others, like the Jeep Gladiator, left much to be desired with underwhelming powertrains.
My test drive of the Toyota Tacoma was a mix of excitement and disappointment—the turbocharged engine was fun, but the cramped cabin didn’t impress.
In a year full of updates, some trucks hit the mark, while others missed it by a mile. Let’s take a closer look at the winners and losers.
1. Nissan Frontier
Ever felt like a vehicle just gets you? The Nissan Frontier might just be that truck.
With its commendable balance of power and agility, this truck handles both city streets and off-road trails with ease. It’s like the Swiss Army knife of midsize trucks.
Did you know? The Frontier has been a staple in the Nissan lineup for decades, solidifying its reputation as a reliable workhorse.
However, despite its strengths, it sometimes falters with a less-than-stellar fuel economy. Still, it’s got charm that’s hard to resist.
2. Jeep Gladiator
While the Jeep Gladiator offers off-road capability that few can match, it falls short in everyday driving performance. The ride is bumpy, and its interior is not as refined as its competitors.
The base engine, while rugged, doesn’t provide the best fuel efficiency, making it less practical for daily commutes.
Additionally, its towing capacity, though strong, doesn’t surpass rivals like the Toyota Tacoma.
For those looking for a daily driver with both rugged charm and smooth handling, the Gladiator might leave you wanting more.
3. Honda Ridgeline
Meet the Honda Ridgeline, where comfort meets functionality. If trucks could wear tuxedos, this one would. Known for its smooth ride and car-like handling, the Ridgeline is perfect for those who prioritize comfort over ruggedness.
It offers a unique in-bed storage system that’s a game-changer for weekend warriors. However, purists might sniff at its lack of traditional truck feel.
Nevertheless, it’s a smooth operator that delivers where it counts, proving that you don’t need to be rough to be tough.
4. Ford Ranger (Base Trim)
The base Ford Ranger is a solid option for those who want a no-frills truck, but it doesn’t shine in comparison to the competition.
With limited features and a less-than-ideal ride quality, it feels outdated next to more modern, well-equipped trucks in the midsize segment.
Its base engine is adequate but not as powerful as some of its rivals, leaving you with fewer options for towing and payload capacity. While reliable, the base Ranger fails to impress in key areas.
5. Chevrolet Colorado (Base Trim)
The Chevrolet Colorado, a true embodiment of American grit and determination. This truck rolls up its sleeves and gets to work, offering a no-nonsense approach to driving.
While the base trim may feel a bit utilitarian, it’s this simplicity that many find attractive. It’s not flashy, but it gets the job done, and sometimes, that’s all you need.
Despite its basic nature, it serves as a solid platform for those who love a project truck to tinker with and customize.
6. Toyota Tacoma (Base Trim)
The Toyota Tacoma in its base trim feels like a missed opportunity for a truck that’s otherwise known for durability.
While the Tacoma excels off-road, the base model lacks the power and refinement that other midsize trucks offer in the same price range.
The interior can feel cramped, and technology features are sparse. If you’re after a no-frills workhorse, the Tacoma still delivers, but if you’re looking for comfort or features, this base model might not be the best choice.
7. GMC Canyon (Base Trim)
The GMC Canyon knows its audience. Tailored for those who seek a balance between work and play, it’s a family-friendly truck with a practical edge.
The base trim may not win awards for luxury, but it’s all about getting the essentials right.
With a focus on functionality, it proves that you can have a truck that’s both versatile and approachable.
However, some might wish for more tech-savvy features. Still, it’s a reliable partner for those who like their trucks straightforward and efficient.
8. Ram 1200 (Global Model)
The Ram 1200, a global model not widely available in North America, is a midsize truck that struggles to stand out. While its design is bold, the driving experience is less impressive.
It offers limited powertrain options and a stiff ride that can leave you uncomfortable on longer trips.
In addition, the interior feels utilitarian, and the overall ride quality doesn’t match up to the competition in the segment.
The Ram 1200 simply doesn’t offer the performance and refinement drivers expect in this category.
9. Chevrolet Colorado ZR2
For those who believe the road less traveled is the only road, the Chevrolet Colorado ZR2 is calling. Built for the wild, this truck thrives on the thrill of adventure.
With its aggressive design and off-road enhancements, it’s ready to take on any challenge you throw its way.
However, its rugged nature comes with a trade-off in comfort. But for thrill-seekers, this is a minor inconvenience in the pursuit of the great unknown.
10. Toyota Tacoma TRD Pro
The Toyota Tacoma TRD Pro is the truck you’d want when serious off-roading is a priority.
With upgraded suspension, locking differentials, and all-terrain tires, this model is designed to conquer trails while offering impressive power.
The TRD Pro is equipped with tech features that make every adventure smooth, and the cabin offers comfort for both on and off-road journeys.
With a reputation for durability, this is the truck that balances performance with everyday reliability, making it a top contender for 2024.
11. Ford Ranger Raptor
The Ford Ranger Raptor isn’t just a truck; it’s a statement. Built for those who dare to defy limits, this truck is all about performance and power.
With its robust build and superior off-road capabilities, it turns rugged landscapes into personal playgrounds.
Though it might be a bit much for everyday errands, its bold nature is what makes it so exciting. If you’re ready to embrace the wild side, the Ranger Raptor is your chariot.
12. GMC Canyon AT4X
The 2024 GMC Canyon AT4X is a midsize truck built for off-road enthusiasts who still want a luxurious feel. With a 2.7L turbocharged engine, it delivers plenty of power for both towing and off-roading.
The suspension is top-notch, and with an upgraded interior that includes high-quality materials and modern tech, the AT4X balances ruggedness with refinement.
Whether you’re headed to the mountains or the worksite, this Canyon offers versatility and style, making it one of the top choices in the midsize truck market.
13. Nissan Frontier PRO-4X
When the going gets tough, the tough get a Nissan Frontier PRO-4X. Built for those who forge their own paths, this truck is all about embracing the wild.
Its rugged design and off-road capabilities make it perfect for adventure seekers. However, all that ruggedness can be a bit rough around the edges on city streets.
Still, for those who live for the thrill of the trail, the PRO-4X is a reliable partner, ready to tackle whatever lies ahead.
14. Jeep Gladiator Rubicon
For those seeking adventure with the added bonus of a pickup bed, the Jeep Gladiator Rubicon is an obvious winner.
It takes the Gladiator’s off-road prowess to a whole new level with advanced 4WD systems, a locking differential, and heavy-duty axles.
The Rubicon is equipped to handle the toughest terrains while maintaining an element of comfort and tech inside.
It’s perfect for those who need a truck that can handle rough roads but don’t want to sacrifice off-road capabilities. Adventure-ready and durabl
15. Honda Ridgeline TrailSport
The Honda Ridgeline TrailSport is the rugged sibling in the Ridgeline family, perfect for those who want a bit more adventure in their drive.
With its enhanced off-road capabilities, it’s ready to tackle trails with aplomb. However, it maintains the comfort and practicality the Ridgeline is known for.
For those who want the best of both worlds—comfort and adventure—the TrailSport is a compelling choice, blurring the line between luxury and ruggedness.
16. Toyota Tacoma Trailhunter
The 2024 Toyota Tacoma Trailhunter is the ultimate choice for those who want to go off-road while still having the reliability of a Toyota.
With added rugged features like underbody protection, all-terrain tires, and specialized suspension, the Trailhunter is built for trailblazers.
Inside, the cabin is comfortable and tech-rich, offering everything from a touchscreen interface to driver-assist features.
This truck combines the toughness of a workhorse with the luxury of a modern off-road vehicle, making it the go-to choice for adventure lovers.